A/B testing is a powerful method in email marketing that involves comparing two versions of an email to see which performs better. This process is essential for optimising email flows and increasing conversions, enabling marketers to make data-driven decisions. 

With Klaviyo, setting up A/B tests is straightforward, providing valuable insights into what resonates with your audience.

Understanding A/B Testing

What is A/B Testing?

A/B testing, also known as split testing, involves creating two versions of an email with a single variable changed between them to identify which version performs better in terms of key metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and conversions.

Why A/B Testing is Crucial for Email Marketing

A/B testing is crucial because it enables marketers to make informed, data-driven decisions. By testing different elements, you can improve engagement and conversion rates, ensuring your campaigns are effective and aligned with your audience's preferences. This iterative process helps refine strategies for better results over time.

Setting Up A/B Tests in Klaviyo

A/B Test Step-by-Step Guide for a Campaign

1. Create Your Campaign:

   • Navigate to Campaigns > Create Campaign > Email.

   • Name your campaign and select the target lists or segments.

     
     

2. Set Up Content:

   • Input the subject line, preview text, sender name, and email address.

   • Create the first version of your email, including all content and images, then click "Save Content."

   
   

3. Create A/B Test:

   • Click "Create A/B Test" at the bottom of the page. This duplicates your email and opens the Campaign A/B test page.

   • Name each variation descriptively.

     

   Source: Klaviyo

4. Edit and Test Variations:

   • Modify one element in the second variation (e.g., subject line, send time).

   • If needed, clone a variation to add more, but limit it to two variations for clarity.

     

   Source: Klaviyo

   
   

5. Configure Test Settings:

   • Select your winning metric (open rate, click rate, or placed order rate).

   • Adjust the testing pool size and duration as needed.

     

   Source: Klaviyo

   
   

6. Review and Launch:

   • Review the test settings, then send your campaign. Monitor the results to identify the winning variation.

     

   Source: Klaviyo

A/B Test Step-by-Step Guide for a Flow

1. Create the A/B Test:

   • In the flow builder, click on the email you want to test.

   • Configure the email content if it is not already done.

   • Click "Create A/B Test" in the Email details panel.

     

     Source: Klaviyo

2. Edit Variations:

   • In the A/B Test tab, edit the name, subject line, and content of each variation.

   • Optionally, add a third variation by cloning an existing one.

   

   Source: Klaviyo

   

   Source: Klaviyo

   

   Source: Klaviyo

   
   

3. Set Test Parameters:

   • Adjust the weight distribution for each variation in the Test Settings.

     

     Source: Klaviyo

   • Configure the winner selection criteria based on metrics like click rate or open rate.

     

     Source: Klaviyo

     

     Source: Klaviyo

4. Publish the Test:

   • Click "Publish Test" to start the A/B test.

     

     Source: Klaviyo

   • Confirm the publication when prompted.

     

     Source: Klaviyo

5. View and Analyse Results:

   • Monitor test results by clicking "View Test" in the flow builder.

     

     Source: Klaviyo

   • Metrics include recipients, opens, clicks, and conversions.

6. Manually Choose a Winner (Optional): If needed, manually select a winner by clicking "Choose Winner" on the results page.

   

   Source: Klaviyo

   

   Source: Klaviyo

10 Essential A/B Tests to Boost Email Conversions

1. Subject Line Testing

Importance of Subject Lines:

Subject lines play a crucial role in email marketing as they are the first thing recipients see, directly influencing whether an email gets opened or ignored. A well-crafted subject line can capture attention, spark curiosity, and motivate the recipient to engage with the email. The effectiveness of a subject line often determines the success of the entire email campaign, making it essential to test and optimise for maximum impact on open rates.

Source: Elastic Email

Test Variations:

• Length: Short vs. long subject lines.

• Emoji vs. Non-Emoji: Testing the impact of including emojis.

• Question vs. Statement: Testing curiosity-inducing questions vs. direct statements.

Expected Outcomes:

Personalised subject lines have a significant impact on open rates, increasing them by an average of 26% (Campaign Monitor). This improvement occurs because personalisation makes the subject line more relevant and engaging to the recipient, which encourages them to open the email.

2. Sender Name Testing

The Impact of Sender Names

The sender's name in an email significantly influences whether recipients decide to open it, as it helps establish trust and recognition. By adjusting the sender name, such as using a personal name like "[owner's name]@company.com," you can create a more relatable and trustworthy impression, which may increase open rates. Consider what you aim to achieve with this change, whether it's adding a personal touch or aligning the sender name with the content of the email to enhance its effectiveness.

Test Variations

• Owner/Team Member Name @company.com

• Support@company.com

• Helpdesk@company.com

• Helpdesk@company.com

• VIPs@company.com

• Giveaways@company.com

Expected Outcomes

Testing sender names can improve open rates by increasing trust and recognition. For example, using a person’s name instead of a generic company name might make the email feel more personal, leading to better engagement.

3. Timing and Frequency Testing

Optimal Send Times

Sending emails at the optimal time can significantly boost engagement, as they are more likely to be opened when recipients are most active. Klaviyo's Smart Send Time feature automates this process by analysing data to determine the best times to reach your audience. By leveraging this feature, you can maximise the effectiveness of your campaigns and ensure your emails are sent at peak engagement times.

Source: Retention Commerce

Test Variations

• Morning vs. Evening Sends

• Weekday vs. Weekend Sends

Expected Outcomes

Determining the optimal send time and frequency can significantly enhance engagement, as emails sent at peak times for your audience are more likely to be opened and acted upon. 

4. Static Image vs. Gifs

Importance of Images vs. GIFs in Testing

Images and GIFs in emails can evoke different reactions from your audience, each serving unique purposes. While static images may be better for conveying clear, straightforward messages, GIFs can add dynamism and catch the eye, potentially increasing interaction.

Test Variations

• Static Image: For straightforward, impactful visuals.

• GIFs: For dynamic, engaging content.

Expected Outcomes

By comparing static images and GIFs, you can determine which type of visual content drives more interaction and click-through rates. GIFs may perform better for dynamic promotions, while static images might be more effective for straightforward messaging.

5. Call-to-Action (CTA) Testing

Importance of CTAs

Call-to-action (CTA) elements are crucial in guiding your audience towards taking a specific action, such as clicking a link, signing up, or making a purchase. A well-crafted CTA can effectively capture attention and direct the user to the next step in their journey, significantly impacting conversion rates. 

Source: Klaviyo

Test Variations

• Button vs. Text Link

• Placement in Email

Expected Outcomes

Testing different CTAs, including button text, colour, and placement, can lead to higher click-through rates. A well-placed and clearly worded CTA often results in more conversions.

6. Personalisation Testing

Benefits of Personalisation

Personalised emails significantly enhance relevance and engagement by tailoring the content to each recipient's specific interests and behaviours. This customisation helps create a more meaningful connection with the audience, making the email feel more personal and directly applicable to their needs.

Test Variations

• Personalised Subject Lines

• Dynamic Content Based on User Data

Expected Outcomes

As a result, personalisation can lead to higher open rates, increased click-through rates, and ultimately, better conversion rates, as recipients are more likely to interact with content that resonates with their individual preferences.

7. Offer Testing

Impact of Offers

Different types of offers can significantly impact the level of engagement and conversion rates in your email campaigns. For instance, discounts, free shipping, or limited-time deals may resonate differently with your audience, driving varying responses depending on what appeals most to them. 

Source: Omnisend

Test Variations

• Discount vs. Free Shipping

• Limited-Time Deals

Expected Outcomes

Testing different offers (e.g., discounts, free shipping) allows you to identify which incentives drive the highest conversion rates. Offers provide a direct incentive for recipients to act, making them a powerful tool for driving sales, especially when tailored to the audience's preferences.

8. Email Length (Long-form vs. Short-form)

Impact of Long-Form vs. Short-Form

The ideal email length—whether long-form or short-form—can vary based on your audience and the type of content being shared. Some audiences may prefer concise, to-the-point messages that quickly convey key information, while others might engage more with detailed, in-depth content that provides a comprehensive overview. 

Test Variations

• Long-Form Content: Detailed information and storytelling.

• Short-Form Content: Quick, actionable messaging.

Expected Outcomes

Testing email length helps determine whether your audience prefers detailed information or concise messages. Understanding this preference can improve engagement and conversion rates, especially when tailored to the content type. 

9. Time Delay Between Emails in Flows

Impact of Time Delay on Flows

The timing of emails in a flow is crucial, especially in re-engagement and abandonment sequences, as it can significantly affect the likelihood of converting a potential customer. Sending an email too soon may seem pushy, while waiting too long could result in missed opportunities. 

Source: Klaviyo

Test Variations

• Shorter Delays: For more urgent communications.

• Longer Delays: For more considered purchases.

Expected Outcomes

Adjusting time delays between emails in flows can optimise engagement by aligning communication with the customer’s buying journey. Shorter delays may suit impulse purchases, while longer delays might be better for considered decisions.

Note: Use a 50% random sample conditional split in Klaviyo to test different time delays.

10. Day Of Send Tests (Campaigns & Flows)

Impact of Day of Send

The day of the week you choose to send emails can significantly impact engagement rates, as different audiences tend to be more active on specific days. For example, some audiences may be more responsive during the weekdays, while others might engage more on weekends.

Test Variations

• Weekdays vs. Weekends

• Specific Days of the Week

Expected Outcomes

Identifying the best day to send emails can maximise open and conversion rates. For example, sending emails on weekdays might perform better for B2B audiences, while weekends could be more effective for consumer-focused brands.

Conclusion

A/B testing is a critical tool in email marketing that allows you to continuously refine and optimise your campaigns for better performance. By systematically testing and analysing different elements—such as subject lines, sender names, send times, and more—you can make data-driven decisions that lead to higher engagement and conversion rates. 

The key is to approach testing with a clear strategy, focusing on the variables that will have the most significant impact on your audience. Implementing these tests in Klaviyo not only enhances your current campaigns but also provides valuable insights for future strategies.

Learn more about effective A/B testing strategies to boost your email conversions!

Get started with a free audit today and discover how A/B testing in Klaviyo can transform your email marketing strategy. Don’t miss out, click here to elevate your results now!